Investors intrigued by Bitcoin have multiple ways to gain exposure, but choosing between buying shares in MicroStrategy (MSTR) or a Bitcoin ETF like IBIT can be a nuanced decision. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide based on your risk tolerance, investment goals, and market expertise
What Is MicroStrategy?
MicroStrategy is a business intelligence company turned Bitcoin juggernaut. Under CEO Michael Saylor, the company shifted gears in 2019, using corporate bonds and stock offerings to buy Bitcoin. As of now, MicroStrategy holds over $4 billion worth of Bitcoin. It essentially acts as a leveraged Bitcoin proxy, but it’s still a regular company with other operational assets.
Key Features of MicroStrategy
- Debt-Fueled Bitcoin Purchases: The company issues bonds, including zero-coupon convertible bonds, to finance its Bitcoin purchases.
- Premium Valuation: Shares trade at roughly three times the value of the Bitcoin on its balance sheet.
- Volatility: Owning MicroStrategy means accepting the dual risk of Bitcoin’s price swings and the company’s financial strategies.
What About Bitcoin ETFs?
Bitcoin ETFs like iBit offer direct exposure to Bitcoin prices without the added complexities of owning or managing cryptocurrency yourself. These funds track the performance of Bitcoin and are simpler to understand and trade.
Key Features of Bitcoin ETFs
- Pure Bitcoin Exposure: ETFs directly track Bitcoin prices without the risk of leverage or operational mismanagement.
- Regulated Structure: ETFs are structured under strict financial guidelines, offering clarity and transparency.
- Less Volatility: While Bitcoin itself is volatile, ETFs avoid the additional risks tied to individual company decisions.
Pros and Cons: A Side-by-Side Comparison
| ASPECT | MICROSTRATEGY (MSTR) | BITCOIN ETF (IBIT) |
| Exposure | Indirect, with leverage risks | Direct Bitcoin exposure |
| Volatility | High (Bitcoin + corporate leverage) | High (only Bitcoin-driven) |
| Complexity | Requires understanding of corporate debt | Simpler to trade and understand |
| Ownership Costs | Potential dilution via stock conversions | Minimal management fees |
| Liquidity | Traded like a stock | Highly liquid |
Who Should Buy What?
- Choose MicroStrategy: If you’re a sophisticated investor who understands corporate finance, appreciates high risk, and seeks leveraged exposure to Bitcoin.
- Choose iBit or Similar ETFs: If you want direct, uncomplicated exposure to Bitcoin with less corporate risk.
At Peak American Investment Advisors, we believe in keeping things simple. For clients looking to invest in Bitcoin, we prefer Bitcoin ETFs like IBIT. They provide direct exposure without the additional financial engineering that comes with owning shares in a company like MicroStrategy.
Ultimately, the decision depends on your goals. If you’re aiming for pure Bitcoin exposure, ETFs are the clear winner. But if you want to ride the waves of volatility with a touch of corporate intrigue, MicroStrategy could be worth the gamble.
CLICK HERE to watch Jared covering this topic on Business First AM.
Disclosures
The sources used to prepare this material are believed to be true, accurate, and reliable, but are not guaranteed. This information is provided as general information and is not intended to be specific financial or tax guidance. When you access a link you are leaving our website and assume total responsibility for your use of the website you are linking to. We make no representation as to the completeness or accuracy of the information provided at this website. Nor is the company liable for any direct or indirect technical or system issues or any consequences arising out of your access to or your use of third-party technologies, websites, information and programs made available through this website. This article is not endorsed or approved by any other Government Agency.
In addition, Peak American specializes in providing strategies and guidance for those who want to increase their chances of “winning” in retirement. We offer no-cost strategy sessions to help you design a custom strategy for your financial future. Contact us today to schedule a meeting!
